Both are Finger Lakes wedding venues in our ranked guide. This page sets their published facts side by side so you can choose the right fit. It is not a review of either venue's service.
Side by side
| Springside Inn | Belhurst Castle | |
|---|---|---|
| Lake | Owasco Lake | Seneca Lake |
| Address | 6141 West Lake Road, Auburn, NY 13021 | 4069 West Lake Road, Geneva, NY 14456 |
| Setting | Historic inn across the road from Owasco Lake, 13 acres | Historic castle on the shore of Seneca Lake, listed on the National Register of Historic Places |
| Published guest capacity | 30 to 300 guests, depending on the space and setup | Castle Ballroom up to 250; Meritage Ballroom up to 160; Edgar's private dining rooms 15–40 each (small weddings under 50) |
| On-site lodging | 7 guest rooms on site, plus the Holland House rental next door (sleeps 10 comfortably, up to 12) | 3 hotels on site; wedding room blocks |
| Catering | In-house catering | On-site events team with customized menus (no set packages) |
| Indoor spaces | Heritage Room, Terrace Room, Oak & Vine | Castle Ballroom, Meritage Ballroom, Edgar's Restaurant in the Castle |
| Ceremony options | Front Lawns, The Grove, and the nearby chapel at The Point at Sand Beach | Lawn ceremonies facing Seneca Lake |
| Guide rank | #1 (Editor's Pick) | #4 |
| Best for | Couples who want ceremony, reception, catering and on-site rooms in one place, with indoor and outdoor choices | Couples who want a castle-and-winery setting on Seneca Lake with large ballrooms |
When to choose Springside Inn
- Historic inn and wedding venue across the road from the western shore of Owasco Lake, on a 13-acre property
- Venue, lodging and in-house catering on one campus
- Indoor and outdoor options year-round on Owasco Lake
- Lattimore family ownership since 1999; site roots to 1851
When to choose Belhurst Castle
- Historic castle on the shore of Seneca Lake, listed on the National Register of Historic Places
- Lawn ceremonies facing Seneca Lake, outdoor bars and a waterside dock
- 3 hotels and 2 restaurants; winery, craft beer and cider; the Isabella Spa-Salon
- Belhurst states it charges no venue fee for its ballrooms
Full profiles: Springside Inn · Belhurst Castle · All venues
FAQ
Which is better for a wedding, Springside Inn or Belhurst Castle?
It depends on the celebration. Springside Inn (#1 in this guide) suits couples who want venue, catering and on-site rooms together on Owasco Lake for 30 to 300 guests, depending on the space and setup. Belhurst Castle suits couples who want a castle-and-winery setting on Seneca Lake with large ballrooms.
How far is Belhurst Castle from Springside Inn?
About 37 min (28.5 mi) from Springside Inn to Geneva (drive-time estimate, no traffic).
Do both venues have lodging?
Springside Inn has 7 guest rooms plus the Holland House. Belhurst Castle: 3 hotels on site; wedding room blocks.
Sources
Checked October 27, 2026. Confirm prices, capacity and availability directly with the venue.
- Springside Inn weddings and events: https://springsideinn.com/wedding-events-at-springside-inn/
- Springside Inn rooms and Holland House: https://springsideinn.com/stayatspringside/
- Springside Inn FAQ: https://springsideinn.com/frequently-asked-questions/
- Belhurst (official site): https://www.belhurst.com/
- Belhurst weddings page: https://www.belhurst.com/weddings/